Tuesday, 28 May 2013

Results

After working on this project thus far, I finally got my results! 

This is the table of the results from the data collected:



Time: 30.0 s (1 dp)
Length
Distance Travelled/cm
Average Distance/cm
(Correct to 1 d.p)
Average Speed/ cm/s
(Correct 3 sf)
-
Trial 1
Trial 2
Trial 3


9 cm
31
29
28
29.3
0.977
7 cm
35
24
32
30.3
1.01
5 cm
46
58
56
53.3
1.78
3 cm
51
63
57
57.0  
1.90
1 cm
71
85
71
75.7  
2.52
Speed=Distance/Time

*Measurements of the length of blade were taken 4cm from the middle of the propeller
Eg 1 cm of the blade of the propeller is 1 cm+ 4 cm= 5 cm from the middle of the propeller

I generated a graph from the results too:





The graph reflects clearly the results collected, which will aid people in understanding the data better.


From the data, I gathered that the shorter the length of each propeller blade, the further the submarine will travel and the greater the speed of the submarine. Increasing the length of blades of the propellers means decreasing specific propeller thrust and higher average inflow velocity. This means that the longer the blade of the submarine propeller, the less kinetic energy it would possess to propel the submarine forward. This 
would lead to a smaller amount of distance travelled when the propeller is longer.


Hence, this proved my hypothesis correct!

So, with these results, I conclude my SIP project!
Thank you for reading!



Monday, 27 May 2013

The Experiment

These are the steps that I took to conduct the experiment:
1.  Fill a bathtub with water and ensure that the submarine does not touch the bottom.
2. Fill the submarine with enough water such that it does is half-submerged in the water. (Volume varies depending on the size of body of the submarine)
3.  Ensuring that the water from the submarine body does not leak, turn the submarine 30 times so that the rubber band in the body will be twisted 30 times. Keep this constant throughout all the different trials.
4.  Determine a starting line in the bathtub. Slowly let go of the submarine and start the stopwatch at the same time.
5.  Stop the stopwatch at 30s (time should be kept constant throughout all the trials). Measure the distance that the submarine travelled.
6.  Repeat the experiment 3 times.
7. Cut 2 cm (markings) off the propeller to test for the next round.. 
8. Repeat steps 1-7 until the length of the propeller reaches 1 cm.
9. Compare and contrast the results.

How to twist the submarine: (twist it 30 times)



Initially, when we put the submarine into the water (with the modified body and propeller) it still did not work.

After observing how the submarine moved, I realized that I did not have enough water in the body to keep the submarine stable. Hence, I added more water so that the submarine will be steadier. Besides that, I also observed that the body of the submarine was spinning too, which was not supposed to be the case. Only the propeller should be spinning. I presumed that it was the lack of stabilising fins that caused this observation. Lastly, the submarine kept going off track and when it hits the side of the bath tub, it will lose kinetic energy. In order to resolve this, I decided to use a chopstick to guide to submarine such that it would not hit the side of the bath tub.

Modifications that I made:
1. Added more water into the body of the submarine 
2. Added more and longer stabilising fins (using chopsticks)
3. Used a chopstick to guide the movement of the submarine

I wasn't able to video all the experiments. Hence, here is the last experiment where the propeller is at 1cm. The video shows that whole process which I used for the previous trials as well.





Next post will be on the results!

Building the Submarine

Making the model of the submarine wasn't easy at all. I had to make some modifications here and there.

I followed the steps below.


1.     Cut the bottom half off a 1.5-L soda bottle using a pen-knife, as shown in Figure A, to make a propeller shape that has five separate curved blades. See Figure A for a picture of the finished propeller.
2.     Drill 2 holes in both the small water bottle cap and the propeller, one in the center and another just off center.
3.     Straighten one end of one of the paper clips and feed it through the hole in the top of the bottle cap and through the center hole of the propeller. The propeller fins should be facing down, curved away from the bottle cap.
4.     Bend the inside ends with the needle-nose pliers, looping it through the second off-center propeller hole to secure the paper clip and two pieces together.
5.     Mark out measurements on the propeller (ie 9cm, 8cm, 7cm etc). You will reduce the length of the propeller to test how the length of the propeller affects the speed of the submarine.

After which, I made the body of the submarine, following the steps below.

1.     To make the submarine, drill two small holes in the bottom of the water bottle, just like the holes in the propeller—one in the center and one slightly off-center.
2.     Straighten one end of the second paper clip and use chopsticks to insert the straight end of the paper clip through the hole of the water bottle, from the mouth of the bottle into the centered hole at the end of the water bottle.
3.     Once you get the straight end out, use the pliers to bend the end over and hook it into the other off-center hole to secure it.
4.     Use the chopsticks again to hook a rubber band onto the paper clip hook inside the water bottle submarine.
5.     Without letting go of the rubber band, hook the other end of the rubber band loop through the paper clip hook inside the bottle cap propeller. If it is too difficult to pull the rubber band using chopsticks, use another paper clip to make a hook and use this to pull the rubber band to the hook in the bottle cap propeller. Make sure the rubber band is tight—the submarine’s rubber band needs good tension or it won’t be able to move. See Figure B.
6.     Use ice cream sticks for stabilising fins. Use a rubber band to tie 2 sticks side-by-side, 4 on the front and 2 at the back of the submarine body.
7.     Using the waterproof sealant, make sure that the paper clip holes are fully sealed. Water can easily move in and out of the submarine if there are still holes, which will affect the experiment. Give the sealant enough time to dry before proceeding with the experiment—see the sealant’s instructions.

How the submarine should look like:
Figure A (propeller)

 Figure B (Propeller + body)

Here are the pictures on how I made the submarine:


Making the body of the Submarine 










 Making the Propeller (1)













After making the propeller, I put the submarine test. However, the experiment was a failure and the propeller was not able to generate enough kinetic energy to propel the submarine forward. The body of the submarine was fine, but it lacked stabilising fins, thus it could not balance.

Things that the submarine was lacking in:
  1. The plastic used to make the propeller was not stiff enough, making it flimsy.
  2. There was not stabilising fin.
  3. There was no gap between the blades of the propeller.
Modifications:
  1. Use a soda bottle which is stiffer and stronger than a mineral water bottle- Allows the propeller to whip the water with more force which will generate more kinetic energy.
  2. Use ice cream sticks and chopsticks to act as the stabilising fins.
  3. Use a soda bottle- the bottom of the soda bottle curves in, which makes the gap between the propeller more obvious.
So with that, I embarked on the second try of making the propeller of the submarine! 

Making the Propeller the Second time








*I used the flame to heat the screwdriver so that it would be easier to drill the hole in.

Time for the experiment with the modified submarine!